Bakery · Maitland
Bakers Cottage Cafe
Starworks Score
Based on live public Google data
What AI tells customers
Here are the top-rated bakeries in Maitland:
Want contact details for any of these?
Not in the answer· #15 of 20
Customers asking AI hear those three names, not yours.
Is Bakers Cottage Cafe your business?
The #1 near you has 434 reviews. You have 330. We close that gap for you.
Not the owner? Scroll down for the full breakdown.
Score Breakdown
3.2 stars — below the 4.5 threshold
330 reviews — strong volume
Website found
Ranked against 19 bakery businesses in Maitland
Areas for Improvement
Bakers Cottage Cafe's 3.2-star rating is below the 4.5-star threshold that top businesses maintain.
High Priority14 competitors in Maitland have a stronger online reputation than Bakers Cottage Cafe.
High Priority
Who's ahead of Bakers Cottage Cafe
These bakery businesses in Maitland have a stronger online reputation than Bakers Cottage Cafe.
| # | Business | Rating | Reviews | Score | Head-to-head |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | M&M Bakehouse Rutherford Maitland | 4.8 | 434 | 91/100 | |
| 2 | The Icky Sticky Patisserie Maitland | 4.5 | 463 | 73/100 | |
| 3 | Blakeney's Pies Maitland | 4.6 | 206 | 71/100 | |
| 4 | The Baker Bee Maitland | 5.0 | 32 | 67/100 | |
| 5 | Greenhills bakehouse Maitland | 4.8 | 64 | 64/100 | |
| 6 | Rutherford Bakehouse Maitland | 4.7 | 154 | 61/100 | |
| 7 | East Maitland Bakehouse Maitland | 4.6 | 123 | 61/100 | |
| 8 | Urban Mill Bakery Maitland | 5.0 | 1 | 59/100 | |
| 9 | Bakers Delight Pender Place Maitland | 4.3 | 115 | 58/100 | |
| 10 | Celebrate with cake Maitland | 5.0 | 4 | 56/100 | |
| 11 | AM's On Church Maitland | 4.8 | 32 | 55/100 | |
| 12 | Van Gool Patisserie Maitland | 5.0 | 30 | 55/100 | |
| 13 | Sammie Cakes Maitland | 5.0 | 22 | 55/100 | |
| 14 | Niche on High Maitland | 4.7 | 78 | 54/100 |
14 competitors in Maitland outrank Bakers Cottage Cafe
Start your 7-day free trial and Starworks helps you climb the rankings — automatically collecting more reviews and replying with AI in your voice, all on autopilot.
20+ new Google reviews in 21 days — or we keep working free.
7-day free trial · 30-day money-back · Cancel anytime
Start Free TrialSetup takes 2 minutes. Backed by our 21-day review guarantee.
Show off your reputation
Add a free, live-updating badge to your website, footer, or email signature.
<a href="https://www.starworks.com.au/score/na:3760510d2d12fb49" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> <img src="https://www.starworks.com.au/api/badge/na:3760510d2d12fb49" alt="Bakers Cottage Cafe — Reputation Score by Starworks" /> </a>
Free forever · no signup · updates automatically as your Google rating changes. More styles & guide
See how all bakeries in Maitland compare
Best Bakeries in MaitlandBakeries nearby
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
About Bakers Cottage Cafe's reputation score.
Where does Bakers Cottage Cafe rank among bakery in Maitland?
Bakers Cottage Cafe currently ranks #15 of 20 bakery in Maitland on Starworks' reputation index, with a score of 45/100. Rankings are based on Google star rating, review volume, and online presence, and update regularly.
Is Bakers Cottage Cafe good? What is their reputation score?
Bakers Cottage Cafe holds a 3.2-star Google rating across 330 reviews, and has a Starworks Score of 45/100 based on rating, review volume, online presence, and how they compare to other bakery in Maitland.
Who are the best bakery in Maitland?
You can see the full ranked list of the best bakery in Maitland on Starworks at starworks.com.au/best/bakeries/maitland. Each is scored on Google rating, review volume, and online presence.
How does Bakers Cottage Cafe compare to competitors in Maitland?
Bakers Cottage Cafe is scored 45/100 and compared head-to-head against other bakery in Maitland on rating, number of Google reviews, and online presence. Businesses with more recent reviews and a higher average rating rank above those with fewer.
How can Bakers Cottage Cafe improve their ranking and reputation score?
The fastest wins are: consistently asking happy customers for Google reviews, keeping the average rating at 4.8+, responding to every review, and keeping website and contact details current. Tools like Starworks automate review requests and AI responses — most businesses see measurably more reviews within weeks, and offer a free trial to start.
How often is Bakers Cottage Cafe's score updated?
Scores are recalculated regularly from the latest publicly available Google data (typically refreshed about every two weeks). Check back to track progress over time.
Want to check another business?
Search for a business